Phred/MILESTONES.md

# Phred Framework Milestones

[← Back to README](./README.md) | [SPECS.md](./SPECS.md)

Phred supports REST and JSON:API via env setting; batteries-included defaults, swappable components.

[↑ Back to Top](#table-of-contents)
## Table of Contents
- [~~M0 — Project bootstrap (repo readiness)~~](#m0-project-bootstrap-repo-readiness)
- [~~M1 — Core HTTP kernel and routing~~](#m1-core-http-kernel-and-routing)
- [~~M2 — Configuration and environment~~](#m2-configuration-and-environment)
- [~~M3 — API formats and content negotiation~~](#m3-api-formats-and-content-negotiation)
- [~~M4 — Error handling and problem details~~](#m4-error-handling-and-problem-details)
- [~~M5 — Dependency Injection and Service Providers~~](#m5-dependency-injection-and-service-providers)
- [~~M6 — MVC: Controllers, Views, Templates~~](#m6-mvc-controllers-views-templates)
- [~~M7 — Modules (Django‑style app structure)~~](#m7-modules-django-style-app-structure)
- [~~M8 — Database access, migrations, and seeds~~](#m8-database-access-migrations-and-seeds)
- [~~M9 — CLI (phred) and scaffolding~~](#m9-cli-phred-and-scaffolding)
- [~~M10 — Security middleware and auth primitives~~](#m10-security-middleware-and-auth-primitives)
- [~~M11 — Logging, HTTP client, and filesystem~~](#m11-logging-http-client-and-filesystem)
- [~~M12 — Serialization/validation utilities and pagination~~](#m12-serialization-validation-utilities-and-pagination)
- [M13 — OpenAPI and documentation](#m13-openapi-and-documentation)
- [M14 — Testing, quality, and DX](#m14-testing-quality-and-dx)
- [M15 — Caching and performance (optional default)](#m15-caching-and-performance-optional-default)
- [M16 — Production hardening and deployment](#m16-production-hardening-and-deployment)
- [M17 — JSON:API enhancements (optional package)](#m17-json-api-enhancements-optional-package)
- [M18 — Examples and starter template](#m18-examples-and-starter-template)
- [M19 — Documentation site](#m19-documentation-site)
- [M20 — Dynamic Command Help](#m20-dynamic-command-help)
- [M21 — Governance and roadmap tracking](#m21-governance-and-roadmap-tracking)
- [Notes on sequencing and parallelization](#notes-on-sequencing-and-parallelization)

## ~~M0 — Project bootstrap (repo readiness)~~
* ~~Tasks:~~
  * ~~Finalize `composer.json` (namespaces, scripts, suggests) and `LICENSE`.~~
  * ~~Add `.editorconfig`, `.gitattributes`, `.gitignore`, example `.env.example`.~~
  * ~~Set up CI (lint, static analysis, unit tests) and basic build badge.~~
* ~~Acceptance:~~
  * ~~Fresh clone installs (without running suggested packages) and passes linters/analysis/tests.~~

[↑ Back to Top](#table-of-contents)
## ~~M1 — Core HTTP kernel and routing~~
* ~~Tasks:~~
  * ~~Implement the HTTP kernel: `PSR-15` pipeline via `Relay`.~~
  * ~~Wire `nyholm/psr7(-server)` factories and server request creation.~~
  * ~~Integrate `nikic/fast-route` with a RouteCollector and dispatcher.~~
  * ~~Define route → controller resolution (invokable controllers).~~
  * ~~Add minimal app bootstrap (front controller) and DI container wiring (`PHP-DI`).~~
  * ~~Addendum: Route groups (prefix only) via `Router::group()`~~
* ~~Acceptance:~~
  * ~~Sample route returning a JSON 200 via controller.~~
  * ~~Controllers are invokable (`__invoke(Request)`), one route per controller.~~
  * ~~Route groups (prefix only) work and are tested.~~

[↑ Back to Top](#table-of-contents)
## ~~M2 — Configuration and environment~~
* ~~Tasks:~~
  * ~~Load `.env` via `vlucas/phpdotenv` and expose `Phred\Support\Config`.~~
  * ~~Define configuration precedence and document keys (e.g., `API_FORMAT`, `APP_ENV`, `APP_DEBUG`).~~
* ~~Acceptance:~~
  * ~~App reads config from `.env`; unit test demonstrates override behavior.~~

[↑ Back to Top](#table-of-contents)
## ~~M3 — API formats and content negotiation~~
* ~~Tasks:~~
  * ~~Finalize `ContentNegotiationMiddleware` using `.env` and `Accept` header.~~
  * ~~Bind `ApiResponseFactoryInterface` to `RestResponseFactory` or `JsonApiResponseFactory` based on format.~~
  * ~~Provide developer‑facing helpers for common responses (`ok`, `created`, `error`).~~
* ~~Acceptance:~~
  * ~~Demo endpoints respond correctly as REST or JSON:API depending on `API_FORMAT` and `Accept`.~~

[↑ Back to Top](#table-of-contents)
## ~~M4 — Error handling and problem details~~
* ~~Tasks:~~
  * ~~Finalize `ProblemDetailsMiddleware` with RFC7807 (REST) and JSON:API error documents.~~
  * ~~Integrate `filp/whoops` for dev mode (`APP_DEBUG=true`).~~
  * ~~Map common exceptions to HTTP status codes; include correlation/request IDs in responses/logs.~~
* ~~Acceptance:~~
  * ~~Throwing an exception yields a standards‑compliant error response; debug mode shows Whoops page.~~

[↑ Back to Top](#table-of-contents)
## ~~M5 — Dependency Injection and Service Providers~~
* ~~Tasks:~~
  * ~~Define Service Provider interface and lifecycle (register, boot).~~
  * ~~Module discovery loads providers in order (core → app → module).~~
  * ~~Add examples for registering controllers, services, config, and routes via providers.~~
  * ~~Define contracts: `Template\Contracts\RendererInterface`, `Orm\Contracts\*`, `Flags\Contracts\FeatureFlagClientInterface`, `Testing\Contracts\TestRunnerInterface`.~~
  * ~~Define config/env keys for driver selection (e.g., `TEMPLATE_DRIVER`, `ORM_DRIVER`, `FLAGS_DRIVER`, `TEST_RUNNER`).~~
  * ~~Provide “default adapter” Service Providers for the shipped packages and document swap procedure.~~
* ~~Acceptance:~~
  * ~~Providers can contribute bindings and routes; order is deterministic and tested.~~
  * ~~Drivers can be switched via `.env`/config without changing controllers/services; example provider route covered by tests.~~

[↑ Back to Top](#table-of-contents)
## ~~M6 — MVC: Controllers, Views, Templates~~
* ~~Tasks:~~
  * ~~Controller base class and conventions (request/response helpers).~~
  * ~~View layer (data preparation) with `getphred/eyrie` template engine integration.~~
  * ~~Template rendering helper: `$this->render(<template>, <data>)`.~~
* ~~Acceptance:~~
  * ~~Example page rendered through View → Template; API coexists with full‑site rendering.~~
  * ~~Rendering works via RendererInterface and can be swapped (e.g., Eyrie → Twig demo) with only configuration/provider changes.~~

[↑ Back to Top](#table-of-contents)
## ~~M7 — Modules (Django‑style app structure)~~
* ~~Tasks:~~
  * ~~Define module filesystem layout (Nested Controllers/Views/Services/Models/Templates/Routes/Tests).~~
  * ~~Module loader: auto‑register providers, routes, templates.~~
  * ~~Namespacing and autoload guidance.~~
  * ~~Core CLI: add `create:module <name>` command to scaffold a module with nested resources.~~
  * ~~ORM‑agnostic module layout (to support Pairity DAO/DTO and Eloquent Active Record):~~
    * ~~`Modules/<X>/Models/` — domain models (pure PHP, ORM‑neutral)~~
    * ~~`Modules/<X>/Repositories/` — repository interfaces (DI targets for services)~~
    * ~~`Modules/<X>/Persistence/Pairity/` — DAOs, DTOs, mappers, repository implementations~~
    * ~~`Modules/<X>/Persistence/Eloquent/` — Eloquent models, scopes, repository implementations~~
    * ~~`Modules/<X>/Database/Migrations/*` — canonical migrations for the module (no duplication per driver)~~
* ~~Acceptance:~~
  * ~~Creating a module with the CLI makes it discoverable; routes/templates work without manual wiring.~~
  * ~~Switching `ORM_DRIVER` between `pairity` and `eloquent` requires no changes to services/controllers; providers bind repository interfaces to driver implementations.~~

[↑ Back to Top](#table-of-contents)
## ~~M8 — Database access, migrations, and seeds~~
* ~~Tasks:~~
  * ~~Integrate `getphred/pairity` for ORM/migrations/seeds.~~
  * ~~Define config (`DB_*`), migration paths (app and modules), and seeder conventions.~~
  * ~~CLI commands: `migrate`, `migration:rollback`, `seed`, `seed:rollback`.~~
  * ~~All persistence usage in examples goes through Orm contracts; can be swapped (Pairity → Doctrine adapter demo optional).~~
  * ~~Add `register:orm <driver>` command:~~
    * ~~Verify or guide installation of the ORM driver package.~~
    * ~~Update `.env` (`ORM_DRIVER=<driver>`) safely.~~
    * ~~Create `modules/*/Persistence/<Driver>/` directories for existing modules.~~
* ~~Acceptance:~~
  * ~~Running migrations modifies a test database; seeds populate sample data; CRUD demo works.~~
  * ~~All persistence usage in examples goes through Orm contracts; can be swapped (Pairity → Doctrine adapter demo optional).~~

[↑ Back to Top](#table-of-contents)
## ~~M9 — CLI (phred) and scaffolding~~
* ~~Tasks:~~
  * ~~Implement Symfony Console app in `bin/phred`.~~ ✓
  * ~~Generators: `create:<module>:controller`, `create:<module>:model`, `create:<module>:migration`, `create:<module>:seed`, `create:<module>:test`, `create:<module>:view`.~~ ✓
  * ~~Utility commands: `test[:<module>]`, `run`, `db:backup`, `db:restore`.~~ ✓
* ~~Acceptance:~~
  * ~~Commands generate files with correct namespaces/paths and pass basic smoke tests.~~

[↑ Back to Top](#table-of-contents)
## ~~M10 — Security middleware and auth primitives~~
* ~~Tasks:~~
  * ~~Add CORS, Secure Headers middlewares; optional CSRF for template routes.~~ ✓
  * ~~JWT support (lcobucci/jwt) with simple token issue/verify service.~~ ✓
  * ~~Configuration for CORS origins, headers, methods.~~ ✓
  * ~~Bind FeatureFlagClientInterface with a default adapter (Flagpole); add small sample usage and env config.~~ ✓
* ~~Acceptance:~~
  * ~~CORS preflight and secured endpoints behave as configured; JWT‑protected route example works.~~ ✓

[↑ Back to Top](#table-of-contents)
## ~~M11 — Logging, HTTP client, and filesystem~~
* ~~Tasks:~~
  * ~~Monolog setup with handlers and processors (request ID, memory, timing).~~ ✓
  * ~~Guzzle PSR‑18 client exposure; DI binding for HTTP client interface.~~ ✓
  * ~~Flysystem integration with local adapter; abstraction for storage disks.~~ ✓
  * ~~Standardize all core service providers with robust driver validation (similar to OrmServiceProvider).~~ ✓
  * ~~Opportunity Radar: Multiple storage disks, log channel management, and HTTP client middleware.~~ ✓
  * ~~Opportunity Radar 2: Storage Disk "Cloud" Adapters (S3), Advanced HTTP Middleware (Circuit Breaker), and Log Alerting (Slack/Sentry).~~ ✓
  * ~~Opportunity Radar 3: Githook Integration, Breadcrumb Automation, and TOC for MILESTONES.md.~~ ✓
* ~~Acceptance:~~
  * ~~Logs include correlation IDs; sample outbound HTTP call via client; file upload/storage demo works.~~ ✓

[↑ Back to Top](#table-of-contents)
## ~~M12 — Serialization/validation utilities and pagination~~
* ~~Tasks:~~
  * ~~REST default: Symfony Serializer normalizers/encoders; document extension points.~~ ✓
  * ~~Add simple validation layer using `Phred\Http\Middleware\Middleware` base.~~ ✓
  * ~~Pagination helpers (links/meta), REST and JSON:API compatible outputs.~~ ✓
  * ~~URL extension negotiation: add XML support~~ ✓
    * ~~Provide `XmlResponseFactory` (or encoder) and integrate with negotiation.~~ ✓
    * ~~Enable `xml` in `URL_EXTENSION_WHITELIST` by default.~~ ✓
  * ~~Opportunity Radar: Storage URL generation, Circuit Breaker persistence (PSR-16), and HTTP client profiling.~~ ✓
* ~~Acceptance:~~
  * ~~Example endpoint validates input, returns 422 with details; paginated listing includes links/meta.~~ ✓

[↑ Back to Top](#table-of-contents)
## M13 — OpenAPI and documentation
* Tasks:
  * Integrate `zircote/swagger-php` annotations.
  * CLI/task to generate OpenAPI JSON; optional serve route and Redoc UI pointer.
  * Document auth, pagination, error formats.
* Acceptance:
  * Generated OpenAPI document validates; matches sample endpoints.

[↑ Back to Top](#table-of-contents)
## M14 — Testing, quality, and DX
* Tasks:
  * Establish testing structure with Codeception (unit, integration, API suites).
  * Add fixtures/factories via Faker for examples.
  * PHPStan level selection and baseline; code style via php-cs-fixer ruleset.
  * Pre‑commit hooks (e.g., GrumPHP) or custom git hooks for staged files.
  * Define TestRunnerInterface and a Codeception adapter; otherwise, state tests are run via Composer script only.
* Acceptance:
  * `composer test` runs green across suites; static analysis passes.
  * CLI tests run via TestRunnerInterface;
  * CLI tests run green per module and across suites.

[↑ Back to Top](#table-of-contents)
## M15 — Caching and performance (optional default)
* Tasks:
  * Provide `PSR-16` cache interface binding; suggest `symfony/cache` when enabled.
  * Simple response caching middleware and ETag/Last‑Modified helpers.
  * Rate limiting middleware (token bucket) suggestion/integration point.
* Acceptance:
  * Sample endpoint demonstrates cached responses and conditional requests.

[↑ Back to Top](#table-of-contents)
## M16 — Production hardening and deployment
* Tasks:
  * Config for envs (dev/test/stage/prod), error verbosity, trusted proxies/hosts.
  * Docker example, PHP‑FPM + Nginx config templates.
  * Healthcheck endpoint, readiness/liveness probes.
* Acceptance:
  * Containerized demo serves both API and template pages; healthchecks pass.

[↑ Back to Top](#table-of-contents)
## M17 — JSON:API enhancements (optional package)
* Tasks:
  * If enabled, integrate `neomerx/json-api` fully: includes, sparse fieldsets, relationships, sorting, filtering, pagination params.
  * Adapters/Schema providers per resource type.
* Acceptance:
  * JSON:API conformance tests for selected endpoints pass; docs updated.

[↑ Back to Top](#table-of-contents)
## M18 — Examples and starter template
* Tasks:
  * Create `examples/blog` module showcasing controllers, views, templates, ORM, auth, pagination, and both API formats.
  * Ensure examples use the external stubs and module-specific CLI command conventions.
  * Provide `composer create-project` skeleton template instructions.
* Acceptance:
  * New users can scaffold a working app in minutes following README.

[↑ Back to Top](#table-of-contents)
## M19 — Documentation site
* Tasks:
  * Build the official documentation site (getphred.com) using the Phred framework.
  * Internal Documentation API: Design a "Documentation Module" that parses Markdown files from the repo to serve them dynamically.
  * ~~Automated TOC Generation: Script to regenerate SPECS.md Table of Contents.~~ ✓
  * Versioned docs and upgrade notes.
* Acceptance:
  * Docs published; links in README; examples maintained.

[↑ Back to Top](#table-of-contents)
## M20 — Dynamic Command Help
* Tasks:
  * Implement a `docs` command in `phred` (e.g., `php phred docs <command>`) that opens the relevant documentation page in the user's browser.
  * Build the `docs` command logic after the documentation site (getphred.com) is functional.
* Acceptance:
  * `php phred docs create:module` opens the correct URL in the default browser.

[↑ Back to Top](#table-of-contents)
## M21 — Governance and roadmap tracking
* Tasks:
  * Define contribution guide, issue templates, RFC process for changes.
  * Public roadmap (this milestone list) tracked as GitHub Projects/Issues.
* Acceptance:
  * Contributors can propose features via RFC; roadmap is visible and updated.

[↑ Back to Top](#table-of-contents)
## Notes on sequencing and parallelization
* M0–M4 are critical path for the HTTP core and should be completed sequentially.
* M5–M8 can progress in parallel with M9 (CLI) once the kernel is stable.
* Optional tracks (M15, M17) can be deferred without blocking core usability.